Thursday, February 3, 2011

Bye Bye Dad (Revised)

In a few days my dad is moving to Connecticut to take care of my grandmother. He's going to stay there for a while and he will visit, but I just feel like it wont be the same. And this makes me think about Harry in the Harry Potter series. His parents are dead and he never got to experience being a kid with a caring family family (not the Dursley's). He doesn't know how it feels to be loved by parents so what could he be missing? The answer is nothing. He doesn't know what it's like to have a family. The theme I'm getting at is kind of like "is it better to have loved and lost or never loved at all". So I wonder how he would feel if he knew his parents, and then they died.

If you think about it, orphans who never knew their parents (and are not adopted) never experience having a real family (unless they're adopted of course). So like I said, what's to miss? But it's not about that. Since I don't have the experience I can't really speak for them realistically but I would think that they aren't hurt by the missing, they are hurt by the desire. The desire to have that perfect family and being loved. Since they don't have it and sometimes will never have it, the desire hurts the most. 

Obviously I'm going to deeply miss my dad when he goes away, but I always think, at least I have the memory. I know my dads coming back and stuff but you know what I mean. But I think sometimes the memories can hurt. Thinking about the good times will lead to you missing them even more. I know I'm going to remember watching all the old movies with him and yelling at the TV when we watch Top Chef. But on the other hand you at least have something to look back on and that's good enough for some people. I just know that I'm lucky, and I'm glad to have a dad.

Countless times throughout the book Harry is reminded of his deceased parents. Whether it's through pictures or seeing them in a special mirror in the earlier books, he can't seem to get away from it. Anyway, my colleague Peter Diller argues at my point. He believes that he doesn't desire a family, he misses his dead family. I disagree with that statement. He was too young to remember anything to do with his parents. If he had, he would have known he was a wizard before a half giant came knocking on their door to tell him.

But going back to theme, I think it is impossible to make the decision, especially because I haven't gone through it, and just in general there's always an opinion. But if I was to make a decision I probably would go with what Harry went through. He made a family. The Weasleys and his friends were his family and in real life it's possible to get adopted. I guess my only question now is how would it change your life if that person was alive, or you originally did have a family? What if Harry had a family? Would he be different? Would he have the tremendous courage he has now?

6 comments:

  1. Oh Teddy. If there is one thing I hate, it is analyzing the Harry Potter series (for sentimental reasons). Your post, has un-done that for me. I would have never considered that perspective. Honestly though, it is kind of an ultimate question "is it better to have loved and lost, then to have never loved at all". I mean, thats Voldemort's view on things right?
    I dont know Teddy, I think you just hit a theme.

    ReplyDelete
  2. teddy.

    i really like this post a lot. i think its a really good point that having memories might actually hurt a person more. not knowing how good it could be could be better then actually having specific things to miss. i can relate also because my dad lives in boston, but the point you've brought is something I've never considered, but totally agree with. and in the end your right, maybe we should just be thankful for what we have.

    -josh.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really enjoyed this post...You connected to your book, gave us your thoughts on orphans, and then gave us memories you have with your dad, it was really different compared to the posts I'm used to...but it was just as good. The format and spelling is great too! Good job Teddy.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Teddyyy!
    i remember like how i felt when you told me that your dad was going away and i kind of just remember how like upset you were. then Josh (molly) told me about this blog post and i almost like cried.
    It makes me really sad when i see any of my friends unhappy or like missing a family member and i just wanna give you a big hug right now but i cant. cause im in the lab and your somewhere else.(remember our epic hug?)
    Butttt since im being graded on this, i have to talk about something other then hugging you.SO i really loved how you related the book to your life. and you know what teddy? i think your your own harry potter. i like that you related your self to the book, but in the opposite way. like you kind of made it so that you had the opposite situation as him. you got to see your dad and will again, but Harry potter never got to. i think if you were to write another post about this, you can write about how memories can affect how you feel, and i guess relate it to harry potter again.
    (youll find a way mr.smarty pants)
    Well i lovedd your post
    -sammiii

    ReplyDelete
  5. Righto then chaps, let's get down to revising
    -Something about the "what's there to miss" comment bothers me. It's so rhetorical. What are they missing? Well, having a family.
    -While obviously this topic is important to you, you should be focusing a bit more on the Harry Potter aspect, after all this is a literary blog.
    -What is this theme? What does have to do with the world and harry potter? How does it effect his choices etc.
    -Lengthen the post, a few more paragraphs would be nice.
    -Hmmmmm. It was good, but needs a central point in terms of literary things.

    ReplyDelete